The mid-year marketing audit: 10 questions to ask yourself

We’re at the halfway mark of the year. Whether you’ve been dragged through this year kicking and screaming or it’s been a smooth ride, this is a great time for a check in on your marketing strategy. You may have settled into a rhythm. However, routine can often breed complacency. The strategies, consumer behaviors, and market conditions that shaped your annual plan last December may look dramatically different today (hello political and economic uncertainties!)

For our own clients, we’re constantly optimizing as we see trends change and consumer behaviour change. The most successful marketing efforts are rigid, they are flexible and adaptive as necessary. A mid-year marketing audit is your tool for that adaptation. It isn't a performance review meant to assign blame. It simply ensures your budget, energy, and resources are focused on the right things for the remaining six months of the year.

To guide this process with your internal team or agency partner, ask these ten critical questions.

1. Which channels generated our highest-quality leads in H1?

It is easy to look at broad metric overviews and celebrate traffic growth or superficial follower increases. Instead consider revenue and closed-loop performance. Identify the specific channels (e.g., organic search, paid LinkedIn, targeted email sequences) that delivered actual customer conversion, and see if they deserve a larger allocation of your remaining budget.

2. Are we burning budget on a "Zombie Campaign"?

A "Zombie Campaign" is an initiative that isn’t technically dead, but it’s wandering aimlessly without producing returns. Often, teams leave ads running or continue producing a specific type of content simply because "that's what we've always done." Pull the hard data. If a channel has consistently underperformed for six months, it’s time to shift those resources elsewhere.

3. How has our Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) shifted since January?

Ad networks are changing rapidly, privacy regulations are tightening, and ad fatigue sets in faster than ever. If your CAC has crept up, your profitability is taking a hit even if top-line revenue looks stable. Pinpoint exactly where the inflation is happening. For example, it could be creative fatigue, rising CPMs, or a drop-off in landing page conversion rates.

4. Is our primary messaging still hitting our audience's current pain points?

Your customer needs can shift quickly and significantly throughout the year. The core problem your product or service solved six months ago might have changed in urgency for your target customer. Look closely at customer support logs, sales call recordings, and social commentary to ensure your content sounds empathetic and hyper-relevant to their immediate needs today.

5. Where is the friction in our current marketing-to-sales funnel?

Marketing can build a brilliant engine, but if the handoff to sales is broken, the budget is wasted. Look at the bridge between marketing-qualified leads (MQLs) and sales-qualified leads (SQLs). Are leads cooling off before sales reaches out? Is there an asset or automated follow-up sequence missing that could smooth out the transition?

6. What did our top three competitors do that we missed?

Marketing doesn't happen in a vacuum. Spend an hour auditing your competitors' recent moves. Did they launch a major new content series? Did they shift their pricing structure? Understanding their momentum helps you safeguard your own market share.

7. Are our marketing technology stacks working for us, or against us?

Take a hard look at your SaaS subscriptions (CRMs, automation tools, SEO tools, analytics suites). Are there duplicate tools? Are you paying for premium tiers your team doesn't have the capacity to use? Streamlining your martech stack can immediately free up operational budget that can be used elsewhere.

8. Is our content production schedule favoring quantity over quality?

Search engines and social media algorithms are increasingly penalizing thin, generic, or AI-generated content that lacks unique value. Assess your production output. Would your brand benefit more from moving from four average blog posts a month to two deep-dive, original data reports or high-production case studies? Depth wins over volume. Answer your audience questions and provide value.

9. Does the team have the creative and technical bandwidth they need?

A strategy is only as good as its execution. Where are the bottlenecks in your processes. Are your designers constantly underwater, resulting in delayed ad turnarounds? Is your marketing manager spending 50% of their time manually pulling spreadsheets instead of analyzing data? Identifying operational bottlenecks and providing solutions prevents burnout and keeps your momentum going.

10. If we had to achieve our goals for the second half of the year with half the budget, what would we cut first?

This question is designed to force clarity. It strips away vanity projects and personal favorites. The answers to this question will show the core drivers of your company's growth.

Working towards a strong finish this year!

The goal of this mid-year audit isn’t to rewrite your entire annual marketing playbook from scratch. It’s to make sure you finish strong for the year. Don’t be afraid to cut out the parts of your marketing strategy that just aren’t working. It will allow you to focus on the most impactful aspects of your strategy.

The choices you make following this audit will define your trajectory going into Q4. Look at the data alongside the creative realities, and make the adjustments necessary to finish the year strong.

‍ ‍

Not sure where to start? Book a free consultation with me!